Back to the home page

In this issue

News
About Songbridge
Need songs?
Samples
Find songs

Pitching songs?

Subscribe info
Associations
Festivals/Events

Articles

Advertise
Contact

SOCAN

INSC

Where's Wendell now?




Kim Cole

AMI

0
Write Songs? or Right Songs?

This past week a reader of our weekly newsletter asked me why organizations such as Songbridge encourage songwriters to focus on HIT songs, geared only to a radio or commercial market. He went on to ask where the opportunities for songs which are thought provoking and insightful are. Well truthfully they are everywhere! Yes, a lot of "commercial" songs are light on social commentary but it's not all fluff, and a handful of singles need to be paired with poignant songs for the balance of the CD.

Artists choose material for their projects with a number of factors to consider, one being that they would like to relate to a song in order to really believe in it and sell it vocally. Yet, from a business practice it would impractical to allow the choosing of material solely on feeling, so, commercial viability plays a factor which is why the producer, manager or label offers guidance on those decisions.


Hit songs sell records. Aren't singles simply sales pitches for the rest of the CD? (A lot of alliteration there and here!). We worked with one artist, as manager and label, who recorded 23 original songs for the project ( what were we thinking) and we settled on 16 of the most "radio friendly" tunes to release and the CD was highly successful for his career. Of those 16 songs, 5 did very well as singles, which spanned almost 2 years of airplay. 16 songs is a lot! It seems safe to say the standard CD release has on average about 10 songs? Of that 10 there are 4 singles, 5 max…. well that's about half the album. So what fills the rest of the CD is the songs the artist "relates to", songs that maybe thought provoking and insightful which is how we gain greater respect for the artists.

I think it is a common mistake for artists to seek as many commercial songs as they can find, because they aren't exactly sure which ones are going to be hits. So, often, CDs are filled with the "safe" formulaic tunes which are what we hear on the air most of the time. Many studies have shown that word of mouth still contributes greatly to record sales, and often it's not the hits people say make the album it is the songs you don't hear that you want to hear when a friend recommends a disc. As I've said many times before, I love a good story song, albeit I'm a big softie and cry at commercials if my hormones are right, or rather, wrong, however, I LISTEN to lyrics. When a new tune comes on the radio I will tell my kids to be quiet for a minute so I can give it my full attention. I like being transported away into a song's story, picturing the narrative, and unfortunately most singles released to radio don't do that for me, those are the album cuts. Maybe folks like me are a minority, though strangely; I'm the major demographic that the powers that be market to: age wise, gender wise, income wise. Has anybody marketed music based on the listeners' intelligence or emotional quotient (if there is such a thing) or based on their political leanings or anything OTHER than population/income figures. It is all determined by who has the money and what can they play between commercials to sell us stuff.

Maybe they need to begin looking at other factors, 'because the state of the industry is quite strained these days. I do know there are new radio licenses being submitted for approval whose formats will be geared towards the 12-17 year old demographic which actually MIGHT make for some thought provoking material. Don't laugh, kids these days are more aware of and concerned about social and ecological issues than the folks over 40 are. Not since the 60's and 70's have young people been so actively involved in and optimistic for social changes, but I digress.

So if current radio formats are geared towards selling us STUFF and most of the music you hear between commercials sound like commercials suitable for the intellectually challenged, don't be disheartened. There is a lot of room for meaningful songs, but face it, you have to pair them with half a CD full of "songs that sell" in order to make money. I know we often post articles that offer tips on how to be a "better" writer, and sometimes they lean towards commercial viability based on various studies we have also directed your attention to because I believe these tools are useful in helping you make a career out of songwriting. "Commercial" is not a four letter word, "poor" is.

Would you rather hold a day job than write commercial music?

Read all our past articles~

©
2005-2006 thesongbridge.com